enshit.club

The data trail

Where the data went.

A reading guide to documented data flows: regulator-backed records alongside published terms for the services people use every day. Those are deliberately different kinds of evidence.

Regulator record: a final order, settlement or finding with a named source. Policy profile:a concise summary of a provider's own published terms. It includes two clearly labelled editorial signals and an exit assessment, not an allegation or evidence that a service sells data. Terms change, so follow the primary source before making a decision.

A red data receipt winding between a phone, router, server, filing cabinet and locked archive.
A connection leaves more than a click behind.

BetterHelp

Final order July 2023

Data
Email addresses, IP addresses and answers to health questionnaires
Documented flow
The FTC said BetterHelp disclosed data to Facebook, Snapchat, Criteo and Pinterest for advertising and retargeting after promising to keep health information private.
Outcome
Final FTC order: ban on sharing health data for advertising or retargeting, consent and deletion requirements, and US$7.8 million for consumer refunds.
FTC final order: BetterHelp health-data sharing

US Federal Trade Commission

GoodRx

Conduct alleged July 2017–April 2020; federal order 2023

Data
Health-condition searches and prescription-medication information
Documented flow
The FTC said GoodRx shared identifiable health information with advertising companies including Facebook and Google, and used some of it for health-related ads.
Outcome
FTC action: restrictions on sharing health data for advertising, deletion notices to recipients, a privacy program and civil penalty judgment.
FTC case: GoodRx health-data disclosures

US Federal Trade Commission

Facebook

FTC order and penalty announced 2019

Data
Profile and friend data available through third-party apps
Documented flow
The FTC alleged Facebook shared users’ friends’ data with third-party app developers despite more restrictive privacy settings, and inadequately controlled developer access.
Outcome
US$5 billion FTC penalty and a privacy order requiring product privacy reviews, stronger developer oversight and restrictions on certain uses of security phone numbers.
FTC privacy order and penalty: Facebook

US Federal Trade Commission

GM and OnStar

FTC order finalised January 2026

Data
Precise location and driving-behaviour data
Documented flow
The FTC says data was sold to consumer reporting agencies, which insurers used in reports and rate decisions.
Outcome
Final FTC order: five-year ban on sharing covered driver data with consumer reporting agencies, plus consent, access, deletion and opt-out requirements.
FTC case: GM and OnStar

US Federal Trade Commission

Avast and Jumpshot

Conduct alleged 2014–2020; order finalised June 2024

Data
Detailed, re-identifiable web-browsing information
Documented flow
The FTC says Avast collected browsing data through antivirus software and extensions, then sold it through Jumpshot to advertising, marketing, analytics and data-broker clients.
Outcome
Final FTC order: ban on selling or licensing browsing data from Avast products for advertising, deletion obligations and US$16.5 million for consumer redress.
FTC final order: Avast browsing data

US Federal Trade Commission

Outlogic (formerly X-Mode)

Final order April 2024

Data
Precise location data, including visits to sensitive locations
Documented flow
The FTC alleged the broker sold raw location data that could be used to track visits to medical facilities, places of worship and other sensitive locations.
Outcome
Final FTC order: prohibition on selling or sharing sensitive location data, deletion requirements and supplier-consent controls.
FTC final order: X-Mode and Outlogic

US Federal Trade Commission

Gravy Analytics and Venntel

Final order January 2025

Data
Mobile location data associated with persistent identifiers
Documented flow
The FTC said Gravy sold data commercially and its Venntel subsidiary sold location-data products to public-sector customers, including government contractors.
Outcome
Final FTC order: prohibition on selling sensitive location data and requirements relating to consent verification, deletion and privacy practices.
FTC case: Gravy Analytics and Venntel

US Federal Trade Commission

Mobilewalla

Final order January 2025

Data
Sensitive location data, including visits to healthcare facilities and places of worship
Documented flow
The FTC alleged the broker tracked and sold sensitive location data without reasonable consent verification, including data sourced from real-time-bidding advertising exchanges.
Outcome
Final FTC order: prohibition on selling sensitive location data and limits on data collection from advertising exchanges.
FTC final order: Mobilewalla

US Federal Trade Commission

InMarket

Final order May 2024

Data
Precise location data and audience segments inferred from visits
Documented flow
The FTC said InMarket collected location data through its apps and third-party app SDKs, combined it with other data and used it to target advertising.
Outcome
Final FTC order: prohibition on selling, sharing or licensing precise location data and sensitive-location audience products, plus deletion and withdrawal controls.
FTC final order: InMarket

US Federal Trade Commission

Published policy profiles

What the services say they do.

A guide to the terms behind the apps, platforms and cloud services people use. Each card links to the provider's current policy and an official exit or export guide.

Signals: 1–5, higher means more.Collection beyond core flags published uses such as advertising, cross-service personalisation or off-platform activity beyond delivering the product's basic job. Sharing exposure flags the breadth of named recipients or advertising/partner disclosures. Switching cost: 1–5, higher means harder to leave. These are editorial reading aids, not legal findings or a measure of security.

Meta consumer services

WhatsApp and Instagram

Editorial signals
5/5Collection beyond core5/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Account, device, activity and off-Meta business-partner information
Published practice
Meta says it uses information across its products and from businesses that use Meta tools to personalise ads and measure advertising. The exact controls and data available differ by product; message content is governed by WhatsApp's separate security and privacy terms.
Reader controls
Review Accounts Centre privacy and ad preferences, connected businesses and activity controls; read the product-specific WhatsApp policy before relying on a setting.
Why these signals
The published terms describe cross-product use, off-Meta business-partner information and advertising measurement—purposes beyond simply delivering a message or social feed.
Switching cost
4/5Instagram information can be exported and WhatsApp supports supported-phone chat transfers, but social relationships, account identity and a usable equivalent of the service do not move with the file.
Meta Privacy Policy

Meta

Export Instagram information

Instagram

Google account ecosystem

Gmail, Google Chrome, Android, Google Play services, YouTube and Google Drive

Editorial signals
4/5Collection beyond core4/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Account, activity, device, app, service-use and email information
Published practice
Google says its policy covers Gmail, Chrome, Android, YouTube, Drive and services integrated into other apps and sites. It describes account activity and personalisation controls, including controls for YouTube History and Web & App Activity; it also says it does not show personalised ads based on content from Gmail, Drive or Photos.
Reader controls
Use Google Privacy Checkup, Activity Controls and My Ad Center; export or delete account content where the individual product provides those tools.
Why these signals
The policy covers a broad account ecosystem, personalisation and advertising services, including activity on third-party sites and apps. It also sets an important content limit for Gmail, Drive and Photos advertising.
Switching cost
3/5Google Takeout can create archives for email, documents, YouTube uploads and account data; Chrome can export browser data. Moving collaborative work, app purchases and recommendation history remains a separate task.
Google Privacy Policy and Privacy Checkup

Google

Download Google data with Takeout

Google

TikTok

TikTok app and web platform

Editorial signals
4/5Collection beyond core4/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Account, device, usage, content metadata and approximate-location information
Published practice
TikTok's US policy says it collects device and user identifiers, can identify activity across devices, and processes user-content metadata. It also describes use of data for content and ad recommendations.
Reader controls
Review in-app privacy, advertising and recommendation settings; check the policy that applies to your country because terms and legal rights vary by region.
Why these signals
The terms describe cross-device identification, content analysis and recommendation or advertising uses in addition to operating the video platform.
Switching cost
4/5TikTok lets users request a data copy, but some data may be unavailable and the export does not recreate the feed, audience or social graph somewhere else.
TikTok US Privacy Policy

TikTok

Request and download TikTok data

TikTok

Microsoft consumer services

Outlook.com / Hotmail and OneDrive

Editorial signals
3/5Collection beyond core3/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Email, files, account, device, usage and subscription information
Published practice
Microsoft says it processes files uploaded to OneDrive to operate the service, and that it discloses personal data to Microsoft-controlled affiliates, subsidiaries and vendors working on its behalf. Its statement says it does not use email, personal files, photos or documents to target ads.
Reader controls
Use OneDrive and Outlook.com to access, download or delete account content where available; use the Microsoft privacy dashboard for account-level controls and review sharing links separately.
Why these signals
The statement includes product-improvement, recommendation and advertising uses, plus affiliates and vendors. It says email and personal files are not used to target ads.
Switching cost
3/5OneDrive files can be downloaded locally and an Outlook.com mailbox can be exported, but Microsoft says mailbox export requires desktop Outlook and shared links or cloud-only files need checking.
Microsoft Privacy Statement

Microsoft

Export an Outlook.com mailbox

Microsoft

Yahoo Mail

Yahoo Mail and Yahoo account services

Editorial signals
5/5Collection beyond core4/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Email content, account, device, activity, advertising and location-related information
Published practice
Yahoo says its Communications Services may analyse and store email content. Its general policy says analysis of retailer and organisation emails can be used to create advertising-interest profiles, subject to opt-out controls and, in some places, consent; it distinguishes those messages from personal emails between individuals.
Reader controls
Use Yahoo Privacy Controls to manage targeted advertising, marketing preferences and account information; read the service-specific communications policy for the mail terms that apply.
Why these signals
Yahoo describes email-content analysis for some advertising-interest profiles, cross-device association and targeted-advertising purposes, subject to its stated controls.
Switching cost
3/5Yahoo documents backing up mail through a third-party app. That preserves messages, but folders, addresses, rules and account-linked services need their own migration plan.
Yahoo Privacy Policy

Yahoo

Yahoo Mail backup options

Yahoo

Dropbox

Dropbox cloud storage

Editorial signals
3/5Collection beyond core2/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Account, usage, device and stored-content-related information
Published practice
Dropbox says it uses trusted third parties to provide, improve, protect and promote its services. Its policy FAQ says it may analyse account activity for product features and, in some cases, to identify people who may be interested in premium services; it also says it does not sell personal data.
Reader controls
Review account privacy and notification settings, connected apps and shared links; use the account privacy tools for access or deletion requests.
Why these signals
The published FAQ describes product, security and premium-service marketing uses, and named trusted third parties acting on Dropbox's behalf; it says Dropbox does not sell personal data.
Switching cost
2/5Dropbox supports downloading files and folders as local copies. Large folders have browser and file-count limits, so test a full export before closing an account.
Dropbox Privacy Policy FAQ

Dropbox

Download Dropbox files and folders

Dropbox

Adobe Creative Cloud

Adobe Creative Cloud and Adobe ID services

Editorial signals
4/5Collection beyond core4/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Account, licence, support, preference, usage and device information
Published practice
Adobe says it collects data to deliver and improve services, tailor experiences and communicate offers. Its policy describes sharing with authorised partners and offers choices for targeted-advertising and cross-contextual advertising controls where applicable.
Reader controls
Use Adobe's Privacy Choices page and product settings to manage preferences, advertising choices and requests to access, correct, delete or export data.
Why these signals
The policy describes tailoring, marketing communications, authorised partners and opt-outs for targeted or cross-contextual advertising where applicable.
Switching cost
3/5Local Creative Cloud files remain accessible after cancellation or downgrade, but cloud-storage limits, collaboration links and product-specific formats still need a planned export.
Adobe Privacy Policy

Adobe

Creative Cloud membership and files FAQ

Adobe

Signal

Signal messaging

Editorial signals
1/5Collection beyond core1/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Phone number, account details and limited service metadata; messages and media remain end-to-end encrypted
Published practice
Signal says messages and calls are end-to-end encrypted and that message and media content is stored locally on the device rather than being available to the Signal service.
Reader controls
Review account-data settings and local backup or transfer choices before changing devices; treat device access and backups as part of the security model.
Why these signals
Signal's published support material describes a deliberately limited service model: message and media content are end-to-end encrypted and not available to the service for advertising or profiling.
Switching cost
4/5Account data can be exported, but Signal says the report does not include messages or media. Leaving a messenger still means rebuilding conversations and group participation elsewhere.
Signal legal and privacy information

Signal

Request Signal account data

Signal

Session Private Messenger

Session private messenger

Editorial signals
1/5Collection beyond core1/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
A pseudonymous account ID and limited connection information; no phone number or email is required
Published practice
Session's app policy says it does not collect or share information, does not require a phone number or email, and does not store identifying device information such as IP address. Its documentation describes end-to-end encryption and onion-routed paths intended to reduce metadata exposure.
Reader controls
Keep control of your account ID and keys, review device access and do not confuse an anonymous account with a verified real-world identity of a contact.
Why these signals
Session's stated model is intentionally unlike ad-funded messengers: pseudonymous IDs, no required phone or email and no collected or shared app data according to its policy.
Switching cost
5/5The privacy model reduces account linkage, but it is not interoperable with other messengers. Session's donation page said core Foundation operations could cease in July 2026 without funding, so verify current service continuity before relying on it for irreplaceable communication.
Session App Privacy Policy

Session

Session continuity notice

Session

Telegram

Telegram cloud chats and Secret Chats

Editorial signals
3/5Collection beyond core2/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Phone number, account, cloud-chat content, device and anti-abuse metadata; Secret Chats are separate and device-specific
Published practice
Telegram says ordinary cloud chats are stored on its servers so they can sync across devices. It distinguishes them from Secret Chats, which use end-to-end encryption and are not stored in the Telegram cloud. Its policy says it may collect IP, device and app metadata for security and anti-spam purposes.
Reader controls
Use Secret Chats only when that device-specific model fits the conversation; review phone-number visibility, location, cloud-chat and account self-destruction settings separately.
Why these signals
Cloud storage is central to Telegram's multi-device product, and the policy describes anti-abuse metadata. Telegram says it does not use data to show ads, while Secret Chats have a different, end-to-end encrypted storage model.
Switching cost
4/5Telegram Desktop can export cloud chats in HTML or JSON, but social relationships and channels do not transfer to another messenger. Secret Chats are device-specific and are not part of the cloud export path.
Telegram Privacy Policy

Telegram

Telegram data and chat export

Telegram

Messenger

Messenger and linked Meta account services

Editorial signals
5/5Collection beyond core5/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Account, device, activity, connection and Meta ecosystem information
Published practice
Messenger is covered by Meta's broader policy, which describes product, device, network, partner and off-product activity information, as well as use across Meta products and advertising systems.
Reader controls
Review Accounts Centre privacy, advertising, connected-business and activity settings; export information before deleting or changing an account.
Why these signals
The published Meta terms describe cross-product use, business-partner information and advertising measurement beyond delivering a private conversation.
Switching cost
4/5Meta supports exporting available account information, but a new messaging service cannot inherit the same conversation history, contacts or group relationships.
Meta Privacy Policy

Meta

Export Meta account information

Meta

X (formerly Twitter)

X social platform

Editorial signals
5/5Collection beyond core5/5Sharing exposure
Data in scope
Account, posts, direct messages, engagement, device, inferred interests, location and advertising information
Published practice
X says it collects activity, direct-message and device information, receives information from ad partners, developers and publishers, and uses information to personalise content and ads. It describes public posts as broadly viewable and searchable.
Reader controls
Review privacy, personalisation, advertising and audience settings; download an archive before deactivating an account and remember that public copies can persist elsewhere.
Why these signals
X's policy describes advertising, inferred interests, off-platform interactions, public availability and affiliate or partner disclosures in addition to running a social service.
Switching cost
5/5X offers an HTML and JSON archive, but posts, followers, public visibility, direct-message relationships and audience context do not transfer to a different network.
X Privacy Policy

X

Access and download X data

X

Product exit index

Can you take it with you?

Product-level exit assessments for the services above. A data export is only the first step; the score reflects how much access, identity, history or workflow remains behind.

WhatsApp

4/5 switching cost

Supported phone transfers move chat history, but conversations, groups and phone-number identity do not become usable on another service.

WhatsApp chat transfer information Meta

Instagram

4/5 switching cost

You can export information, but followers, recommendations, direct-message relationships and account identity stay on the network.

Export Instagram information Instagram

Gmail

3/5 switching cost

Takeout creates an archive, but a real move still needs another mail provider or client and a mailbox import plan.

Download Google data with Takeout Google

Google Chrome

2/5 switching cost

Bookmarks and selected signed-in browser data can be exported; extensions and web habits still need manual replacement.

Export Chrome data Google

Android and Google Play services

4/5 switching cost

Direct transfer can move much data, but some apps, app data, accounts and manufacturer-specific features do not transfer cleanly.

Android backup and transfer data Google

YouTube

4/5 switching cost

You can download your uploads, but audiences, subscriptions, comments, recommendations and creator tools are platform-specific.

Download uploaded YouTube videos YouTube

Google Drive

2/5 switching cost

Takeout can create an archive; check formats, sharing links and collaboration workflows before moving important work.

Download Google data with Takeout Google

TikTok

4/5 switching cost

A data copy is available, but the feed, audience and social graph are not portable to a replacement platform.

Request and download TikTok data TikTok

Outlook.com / Hotmail

3/5 switching cost

Mailbox export is supported, but Microsoft says it requires desktop Outlook and is not a one-click transfer to another mail service.

Export an Outlook.com mailbox Microsoft

OneDrive

2/5 switching cost

Files and folders can be downloaded, but shared links, online-only files and specialised content need a deliberate migration check.

Download OneDrive files and folders Microsoft

Yahoo Mail

3/5 switching cost

Yahoo documents backup through a third-party mail app; folders, rules and account-linked services need separate migration work.

Yahoo Mail backup options Yahoo

Dropbox

2/5 switching cost

Files and folders can be downloaded as local copies, but large-folder limits make a tested export important before leaving.

Download Dropbox files and folders Dropbox

Adobe Creative Cloud

3/5 switching cost

Local files remain accessible after cancellation or downgrade, but cloud limits, sharing links and native formats still need a plan.

Creative Cloud membership and files FAQ Adobe

Signal

4/5 switching cost

The account report excludes message and media content; moving to another messenger also means rebuilding groups and conversations.

Request Signal account data Signal

Session Private Messenger

5/5 switching cost

Its pseudonymous, non-interoperable design makes moving conversations to another messenger difficult. Session has also published a continuity warning: verify the network's current status before depending on it.

Session continuity notice Session

Telegram

4/5 switching cost

Cloud chats can be exported from Telegram Desktop, but social relationships and channels do not move. Secret Chats are device-specific and deliberately outside cloud synchronisation.

Telegram data and chat export Telegram

Messenger

4/5 switching cost

Meta can export available information, but a different messaging service cannot inherit the same history, contacts or group relationships.

Export Meta account information Meta

X (formerly Twitter)

5/5 switching cost

An HTML or JSON archive preserves an account snapshot, not its public identity, audience, direct-message relationships or platform visibility.

Access and download X data X